Queensboro Bridge and Manhattan high-rises above an East River waterfront construction site.

When Telling the Truth Costs You the Listing

  • Dezireh Eyn

Every listing presentation gets to the point where the agent has to say a number out loud. Is it what they believe the property is worth, or what they think will get them hired? Sometimes those are the same number. Often they aren't.

Say three agents are competing for a listing. Two suggest asking $3 million. The third has gone through the comps, the competition, and what buyers are actually doing, and recommends $2.6 million. Naturally the seller likes the higher number. Nobody wants to be talked out of $400,000.

But the most attractive valuation isn't necessarily the best advice. In a business where the first scoreboard is whether you won the listing, that's a conflict we don't discuss enough.

The market is becoming less forgiving

Redfin reported this week that national home-sale prices fell 0.4% year over year in October, the first annual decline in more than three years. And 36% of homes sold nationally had at least one price cut, the highest share Redfin has ever recorded.

New York City doesn't move in lockstep with the national market, but we're feeling the pressure here too. StreetEasy's September report showed Manhattan's median asking price down 6.9% from a year earlier and median time on market up to 102 days.

A recent Marketproof study of nearly 29,000 Manhattan listing campaigns between July 2024 and June 2026 makes the point sharply. Listings that went into contract within 60 days sold at a median of 1.2% below their original ask. Listings that took more than 180 days sold at a median of 10.6% below.

Plenty of homes sit for reasons that have nothing to do with price. Still, when the market isn't supporting an asking price, the seller's expectations usually come down eventually. In a lot of cases, the market ends up having the conversation the agent avoided at the listing appointment.

The difference between ambition and advice

Pricing isn't an exact science. Two good agents can walk through the same apartment and come up with different numbers, and a one-of-a-kind property can justify going out ambitiously. So I'm not saying the agent with the lowest number is the honest one. What matters is whether the recommendation comes from professional judgment or from a guess about what it will take to get the exclusive.

Sellers are allowed to be optimistic and to test the market within reason. Our job is to make sure they understand what they're risking. Sometimes that means telling them something they don't want to hear, and sometimes you lose the listing because of it.

I've watched agents spend years getting good at valuation, then lose a listing to someone willing to say a bigger number. The agent who overpromised may be back in a few months recommending a price reduction. By then they have the listing agreement, and they may still get paid. For an industry that talks about trust as much as ours does, that's a strange way to set up the incentives.

What are brokerage leaders rewarding?

Every brokerage says it values integrity. That's easy to put on a website and much harder to stand behind when it costs the company money.

Production matters. But a production number doesn't tell me much about an agent's judgment or how well they take care of a client. I want agents who can back up a pricing recommendation, who know where advocating for a seller ends and humoring an unrealistic expectation begins, and who are secure enough to walk away from a listing that would require them to lower their standards.

That puts responsibility on people like me. If we ask agents to make hard calls, we have to stand behind them when they do. We can't praise integrity at the company meeting and then judge everyone by listing count.

Confidence also isn't the same as certainty. The best agents I know are honest about the limits of the data. They can walk a seller through a pricing strategy without claiming to know exactly what a buyer will pay, and that's why sellers trust them.

The business we're willing to lose

Winning someone's business and earning their trust usually go together, but not always. Sometimes the best advice an agent can give is the advice that loses them the listing, and integrity doesn't always pay off right away. If we want to raise standards, we should admit that instead of repeating the usual line that honesty is good for business.

We spend a lot of time talking about how to win more listings and grow market share. I'd like us to also talk about which listings we're willing to walk away from. You find out what a company's standards really are when keeping them costs something.

Follow Me on Instagram